"Crystal Rain," Tobias S. Buckell

Pros: Stunning world; amazing characters; very organic feel; highly unusual
Cons: None
Rating: 5 out of 5

Review book courtesy of Tobias S. Buckell.


Twenty-seven years ago, John deBrun washed up on the shores of Brungstun with no memory of who he was or where he was from. Some kind of instinct pushed him to attempt a journey to the far, frozen North, where he nearly died, but he returned without answers. He married and had a son, yet his nightmares never faded and he never remembered anything more about himself.

One day the lands of Nanagada are invaded by their old enemies, the Azteca, and the Azteca’s terrifying, alien gods: the Teotl. The Azteca capture Brungstun, but John escapes with the help of an Azteca traitor—a double-spy who seeks to wrest a set of valuable access codes from John’s missing memories so the Teotl will have access to something called the Ma Wi Jung. John believes his wife and son to be dead, but his son, Jerome, was saved by a deadly, inhuman, frightening man called Pepper who claims to be an old friend of John’s.

Meanwhile, Dihana, the Prime Minister of Capitol City and the Nanagada, works furiously with General Haidan of the mongoose-men and the infuriating Loa to protect the Nanagada from the vast armies of the Azteca. But unless something changes, it’s just a matter of time until they fail, and all their people are enslaved or, worse, sacrificed to the Teotl.


It’s difficult for me to believe that Crystal Rain is Tobias S. Buckell’s debut novel—it’s that good. The feel is incredibly organic, as though the world unwinds naturally before us. It feels as though the reader is experiencing the story of John and the Nanagada rather than reading a constructed fiction. Rather than presenting us with artificial cliff-hangers and twists, Buckell allows any surprises to come out in natural pieces throughout the story, such that if you figure something out ahead of time there’s no feeling of let-down when it’s revealed, because the story doesn’t rely on that twist of surprise for its pacing and interest.

Buckell manages to do several things extremely well that even very experienced writers tend to have difficulty pulling off. He tells the story through quite a few different points of view, yet I never feel confused as to who’s doing the telling; each character is quite unique, distinct, and fully fleshed out. Stranger yet he manages to use one of John’s enemies (his accompanying would-be interrogator) as a point of view character without spoiling the plot, ruining the pacing, alienating the reader, or otherwise throwing off the book.

He has his characters speak in their own unusual dialects and rhythms—usually a terrible thing for a writer to attempt as it swiftly gets old and almost never adds anything—yet it works. It only took me a brief time to get used to it, then it felt more and more natural until I found myself thinking in it at times. The use of dialect is extremely consistent, and as a matter of characterization dialect is every bit as important in this book as any other measure.

But wait, there’s more that Buckell does that most writers couldn’t pull off. Nanagada is a colony settled by space-farers. Due to various past events, it retains very little of the technology of its ancestors and has, at best, an imperfect understanding of even those few items it possesses. The Teotl and Loa are aliens worshiped as gods, and some bits of technology aren’t quite as lost as everyone believes them to be. In many writers’ hands this would lead to a very mixed-up genre feel, a confusion of identity that would rob the story of some of its potential for a consistent, strong world-feel. In Buckell’s hands it all comes together in a heady melange that I found it difficult to extricate myself from—every time I put the book down I found my head trapped in thoughts of the world and its characters.

I’m not sure I can adequately describe the number of ways in which this book succeeds. Suffice it to say, I look forward to devouring each of Buckell’s future novels as they come out!

Posted in Reviews Tagged with: , , ,
10 comments on “"Crystal Rain," Tobias S. Buckell
  1. booklogged says:

    Wow Heather! You write a great review. You’ve definitely sold me on this book. I don’t think it would have called out to me from the shelves of a bookstore, but it certainly does from your post. Thanks so much.

  2. booklogged says:

    I just went to bookmooch and put Crystal Rain on my wishlist. Unfortunately, no one had it up for grabs. πŸ™

  3. heather says:

    booklogged: Oh good, I don’t have to feel badly now. I was feeling somewhat guilty that I was having trouble putting into words all the reasons why this book so appealed to me. πŸ™‚ I’m lucky I have such a tolerant husband—he put up with me keeping him up after we went to bed one evening trying to explain to him what I thought was so amazing about it, the better to be able to put it into words later. I guess I must have convinced him too though, since it’s now on his TBR pile!

  4. Booklogged: email me at tobias@tobiasbuckell.com, I would be happy to stick you on my review copies list.

    Heather, I’m so pleased you enjoyed this book!


  5. dew says:

    Yeah, I’m sold on this book, too! I figure even if I don’t like it (not a huge sci-fi fan, though I like some) my son will love it. Great review!

  6. Court says:

    I used to positively love the scifi genre, but in the past few years I stopped reading it almost completely. I keep looking for a book that will help me get back into the genre, and this one sounds like it might do that. πŸ™‚

  7. heather says:

    tobias: I started Ragamuffin and am already hooked. I kept picking it up during slow moments in something else last night and then putting aside the first activity for the book.

    dew: Cool. πŸ™‚

    Court: Well then I hope it does the job! I enjoy SF, but I do find I go back and forth on actually reading it. I think because, while there’s some awesome SF out there, it can be difficult to find. So I end up getting frustrated with the genre and going back to other things. Oddly, a halfway-decent thriller, say, can still be more fun than a halfway-decent SF book, IMO, since a halfway-decent thriller still tends to draw me in just by nature of the genre. So I think I’m a bit more tolerant of sub-par quality in that genre, as well as things like mysteries. This probably isn’t exactly ‘fair,’ but it’s a quirk of the genres. Even a so-so mystery can still catch at your imagination, and a comparatively boring thriller can still be kind of exciting. Whereas a not-so-great SF novel often doesn’t have so much to hang on to.

  8. SciFiChick says:

    I just started this one, and I’m finding it hard to put down!

  9. Stephanie says:

    Wow. Does a review get any better?? I guess I’m just going to have to go out and buy it!! (or hope someone else does! I’ve got it my wishlist now!)

    GREAT Review!

  10. heather says:

    SciFiChick: Ragamuffin‘s pretty darn hard to put down too. πŸ™‚

    Stephanie: Thanks and I hope you enjoy the book as much as I did!

6 Pings/Trackbacks for ""Crystal Rain," Tobias S. Buckell"
  1. […] Dreams really enjoyed reading Crystal Rain: It’s difficult for me to believe that Crystal Rain is Tobias S. Buckell’s debut […]

  2. […] 500+ reviews of books, kitchenware, and more! « “Crystal Rain,” Tobias S. Buckell […]

  3. […] imagination, and I do recommend reading it. As I said, this is Ms. Mallet’s debut novel, and Tobias Buckell aside, debut novels aren’t perfect. Part of the fun of a new author is watching them grow as […]

  4. […] over by an author’s debut of one sort or another. First time it was Tobias Buckell’s Crystal Rain, and now it’s Bettie Sharpe’s Ember. And in the case of Ember, I wasn’t even […]

  5. […] about books have heard of most of my favorite authors, at least in passing: Anne Bishop, Garth Nix, Tobias Buckell. However, almost no one has heard of Thomas Ligotti. He has a very loyal cult following among a […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.