"Through the Veil," Shiloh Walker

Pros: Strong characters, fascinating world-building, intricate plot
Cons: If there were any, I was too wrapped up to notice them!
Rating: 5 out of 5

Review book (uncorrected proof) courtesy of Penguin Group.
Expected publication date: 6/3/2008.
Visit Shiloh Walker’s website.


I love the current trend to blend genres. I can’t help it; when I was writing fiction, that was how I loved to write, without fitting a given story into a box labeled ‘horror’, ‘fantasy’, or ‘SF’. Shiloh Walker’s Through the Veil spans so many genres: romance, erotica, fantasy, science fiction, horror, paranormal. What makes it so good is the fact that it’s a story first and any genre considerations are simply a part of making that story what it needs to be. But I’m getting ahead of myself.


Lee is a professional artist. She’s an orphan, raised by the system after she was found wandering alone in a field as a child, but she’s made a good life for herself. Despite that, however, she’s plagued by nightmares. She wakes up in the morning with injuries—a black eye, a sprained ankle, broken bones—all of which heal unusually quickly. She’s haunted by faces, one of which is a man with the face of an angel who rails away at her for leaving him. He insists that her place is with him, in his world, fighting against the demons and Warlords from other realms that invade their home. Without her, the resistance is doomed. How can she find her way to him, and would she want to if she could? Is he real, or is she going insane? And even if she could join him, what could she do to save his world that everyone else can’t?


Open letter to Ms. Shiloh Walker:

Dang, woman! I got so caught up in this book that I think I ignored my husband for an evening while reading it. I became so mired in your vivid worlds that after finishing the book, I couldn’t talk about anything else for hours. I had to pick up a non-fiction book to read next because I couldn’t slip into another fictional realm just yet. I went to Amazon and started adding your insanely prolific back-catalog to my wishlist, hinting to my husband that our anniversary is coming up next month. I found myself desperately wishing this to be a part of a trilogy that I had in my hands, with more books that I could move straight on to, even though I normally shun series because I hate having to wait between books. You hearing me, there? Go write more in this universe! That’s… well, that’s me begging, really.

Your characters are strong and vivid, easy to love, hate, and enjoy. They’re complex, such that even the best ones have their flaws and the worst ones their redeeming notes. Your world-building is fascinating and intricate, providing a stunning, immersive, and difficult-to-detach-from experience. Your plotting is complex and wonderful—you don’t fall back on allowing the romance to be the plot, which tends to result in a story that doesn’t have enough conflict or surprises, and to my mind is the most common mistake that some romance authors make. But not you—you obviously know better.

The only thing that even mildly bugged me was the length of time it took for the heroine to come to terms with what was going on with her, but to be honest, that’s such an individual judgment (and it was so borderline, and done so well) that I can’t even legitimately call that a negative.

So I’m going to stop here, and urge you to please, PLEASE, go write more (heh, as if your already-published books weren’t enough to keep me busy on top of my pile of review books). After all, I’ll have a birthday later this year that I’ll need to drop hints for, too…


(Standard notes: explicit non-kinky sex; adult situations; mild blood & gore)

Posted in Reviews Tagged with: , , , , , ,
10 comments on “"Through the Veil," Shiloh Walker
  1. Heather, I’m glad you liked the book. Uh… no comment yet on whether or not more are forrthcoming, but it’s more than likely.


  2. heather says:

    Shiloh: *does a happy dance* Woot! Need more! I’m addicted, I tell you, addicted! (And seriously embarrassing myself here…)

  3. Stephanie says:

    WOW, that’s some review! I just love it when I finish a book and can’t wait to share it with my friends!

  4. bettie says:

    Great review! This book was on my List before, your review just earned it a spot on my calendar. For the record, there are three books left on my calendar for 2008. Three books on whose release days I have blocked out an evening, and will preemptively tell all of my loved ones to leave me the hell alone. Even the cats.

    Dear June 3rd,
    Why do you have to be so far away?

  5. heather says:

    Hi bettie! You know, I used to have so few favorite authors, so few whose work I could totally rave about. Mostly Anne Bishop, with a couple of others right behind her. Now there’s you, and Shiloh, and Tobias Buckell, all from the last year. I’ve never been the fangirl type; it’s disconcerting to become one at 35. 😉

  6. heather says:

    Stephanie—it’s really fun to find a book that I enjoy that much—and almost as much fun to rave about it!

  7. Darla D says:

    This sounds like a lot of fun! Is it part of a series, do you know? Are there others that should be read first? If not, I’ll wait for this one to come out so I can start with it.

  8. heather says:

    Darla: It sounds like there might be more books to come in the same world (fingers crossed!), but that this is the first. So I’d go ahead and grab this one when it comes out.

  9. Darla D says:

    Thanks, Heather – it’s now on the list! 🙂

  10. Taylor Timms says:

    Really intriguing review. My favorite genres are horror, science fiction, and erotica. I bet I would find this book very good. I will check it out myself. Thanks for posting it.

    Taylor Timms
    Author of Beautiful Breasts Pictures book.

5 Pings/Trackbacks for ""Through the Veil," Shiloh Walker"
  1. […] their work, they can be sure I mean it. For instance, today’s review of Shiloh Walker’s Through the Veil—you can bet I meant every last thing I said in there. If I was the kind of reviewer who only […]

  2. […] a review described it better than I could…over at Errant Dreams: Shiloh Walker’s Through the Veil spans so many genres: romance, erotica, fantasy, science […]

  3. […] Jambrea’s Review * Errant Dreams * Kwips & Kritiques * The Romantic […]

  4. […] reviewed by: Jambrea’s Review Errant Dreams Kwips & Kritiques The Romantic Posts Best Fantasy Stories Sci Fi Chick Stacy’s […]

  5. […] “Through the Veil,” Shiloh Walker […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.