"Down to a Sunless Sea," Mathias B. Freese

Pros: Beautiful prose-poetry; an astounding empathy; great courage
Cons: It helps to have a decent history & literature background
Rating: 5 out of 5

Review book courtesy of the author
Visit the author’s site.


I’m slightly at a loss when it comes to reviewing Mathias B. Freese’s Down to a Sunless Sea. The author is a psychotherapist and teacher, and he has produced a remarkable book of short stories that, frankly, feels beyond my ability to adequately review. I’ll try to get a few of my thoughts about it on paper, and hopefully they’ll be able to help you figure out if you’d be interested in reading Down to a Sunless Sea.

This is a very literary book—the words curl in and out in a sort of prose poetry, and I know there were historical and literary references I didn’t catch. It is this without being elitist or pompous in the way that some literary pieces can be; there’s no sense of the author trying to stump or impress the reader with his base of knowledge. He includes what’s relevant and necessary to his pieces and that’s all.

Unlike many short story collections by a single author, this one varies dramatically from piece to piece. Each one is told in a voice appropriate to its subject, whether that’s a barely literate high schooler scornful of his English teacher or the inner chatter of an obsessive-compulsive.

What ties these stories together is Freese’s remarkable empathy, his astonishing ability to get inside the heads of his characters and simply present them as who they are, show the world from their eyes without any outside judgments clouding the issue. A young man with a lame arm and foot (he’s named them Ralph and Lon) swears and speaks frankly about everything from masturbation to the way he talks. A sighting of a bear in a rural community serves as a lesson in fear and normalcy. An old woman’s chat with a boy on a bench one evening is a heart-breaking look at what it can mean to live life after a concentration camp. Several stories touch on the Holocaust from various directions, while others examine the everyday slings and arrows that leave their marks—for good or ill—on our psyches.

These are fascinating stories, and I don’t know how to adequately express how worthwhile they are. I don’t think I’ve ever said this about a book before, but I feel privileged to have read this collection.

“When I was a little girl not much older than you, I had the most beautiful arms. They were like alabaster. Do you know what alabaster is?…I suppose not, little boy. Anyway, child, I had a lovely presence, or so I learned from my parents. My mother said I glowed from within, like ivory. Alabaster, my child. My father—he’d been dead a long time—called me his Grecian girl, Ionic. You know what Ionic means?…How could you, little boy?

“A darkness came. It was not a fairy tale darkness. My beautiful arms were draped in shadow, and the Grecian urn shattered. Do you know what it is to be broken, in pieces, my child?…I suppose not. How could you?”     —from ‘Alabaster’

Posted in Reviews Tagged with: , ,
7 comments on “"Down to a Sunless Sea," Mathias B. Freese
  1. J. Kaye says:

    Great review! Steve – hubby – loved this book!

  2. Wow, this does sound good! I am not familiar with the author or book, but I will definitely be looking for it. I really like books that capture a character so completely.

  3. i felt your review was thoughtful and one can always relish being appreciated; in your note to me you expressed an interested in my other work. if you google, The i Tetralogy, a historical fiction on the Holocaust, perhaps you might consider this for a further review. however, it is strong stuff. An interview with me by david herrle is on my site.
    kind regards,

  4. This book sounds really intriguing. I’ll look out for it. Wow, you got a comment from the author, too 🙂

  5. heather says:

    J. Kaye: It’s really a remarkable one, isn’t it?

    Feline: I hope you enjoy it! Some of the stories are somewhat dark, but they’re also beautiful.

    mathias: If I can dig myself out from under my review pile I’ll look forward to reading your book; onto the Amazon wishlist it goes! Thank you for coming by.

    gentle reader: Do let me know what you thought of it if you end up reading it!

  6. I agree. This is not a easy book to read and review. However, it was worth it. I am going to look out for his other work.

    BTW, I linked this to mine!

    Here is my Review!

  7. Read this book a while ago, and you definitely it the nail on the head with the review.
    You can definitely pick-up on the shrink (Psychotherapist) mentality in this book.

    I would agree that its worth the read…

1 Pings/Trackbacks for ""Down to a Sunless Sea," Mathias B. Freese"
  1. […] J. Kaye’s Book Blog, Melody’s Reading Corner, Book Chase, Booking Mama, Books Love Me, Errant Dreams Reviews, Kay’s Bookshelf, Musings of a Bookish Kitty, Reading Room, and Puss Reboots. Possibly […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.